Welcome to the sister thread for "Best alternative Lord of the Rings cast". Rule: 1. The actors/actresses cannot already be in the movies, i.e. Liv Tyler as Eowyn. 2. Keep it semi-serious. We want to have fun here but Kermit the frog as Aragorn would never have happened in a real life film. If you want to suggest Kermit, make sure the entire thing is muppet themed. The same goes for bad dramatic actors in a bad dramatic cast ect. Here's mine. Frodo - Jim Carrey Gandalf - Rick Moranis Aragorn - Bill Murray Samwise - Mike Meyers Merry - Rowan Atkinson Pippin - Martin Short Legolas - Johnny Depp Gimli - Keith Lonnecker Boromir - Brendan Fraisure Saruman - Steve Martin Arwen - Lily Tomlin Galadriel - Dolly Parton Wormtounge - Wallace Shawn Elrond - Tommy Lee Jones Theoden - John Cleese I'll think of some more later.