Discussion in 'Polls' started by finrod, Dec 1, 2003.
Just curious: which Tolkien book is most popular amongst the members of TFF?
The Silmarillion rocks. :banana: :banana:
The Book of Lost Tales definately, for the Fall of Gondolin alone!
I luv the fall of Gondolin as well but the Silmarillion is so much larger.
silmarillion, beleg cuthalion, is da elf, damn that turin!!!!!!!
Seriously, I'd rather have a story about Beleg then Turin anyday!
*runs as the angry Turin fans chase him*
No, I never really liked Turin either, Tuor was cool though.
BOLT most defiantly mainly because i liked the explanation of tolkiens world better but thats my opinion
Beleg and Tuor are my favorites. But Beren, Feanor, Turin, Turgon, Thingol, and Glorfindel are just amazing. And don't forget Huin! What an amazing character.
My father and I were watching The Two Towers and he commented on how not even Peter Jackson could have come up with this story if the books weren't written.
your Father is a wise person
Polls are to be in the POLLS area.
You don't have to tell me that.
Does anyone know if Ted Nasmith is doing or has done an illustrated Book of Lost Tales like he did the Silmarillion?
I personally enjoyed 'The Hobbit'. It was enjoyable to read! But, ya know, I like 'em all.
Lanterne Ted nasmith has not done an illustrated version of lost tales to my knowledge but my copy has illustrations by JRR Tolkien in it
I liked the hobbit the most. the Silmarillion was just too boring, and the lord of the rings had too many stupid songs...im not saying i didnt like them or anything
i havent read the book of lost tales yet so ill get back to you when i do...
i like the sil (which i am reading at the moment!) and the hobbit!
you cant pick 2 bools so i went for the sil!
I also really like the Silmarillion. It's so much deeper than the other books (Rings and Hobbit) and the stakes are so much higher.
Yea, it a really moving (as in fealing wise not literally) book! I was reading the bit where Finwe dies in the book and it feals as though its has happened! it not just a book! (Kind of hard to explain!) As with all his books he makes the books feem as though they are true, and not just fantasy!
Maybe, da Hobbit, cuz ita da first Book of Tolkien, dan i read ...
Separate names with a comma.