All right, this may be obvious to some, but it is an on-going debate in my house. Frodo, Sam, Bilbo, and Gimli all end up going to Valinor. Now does this mean they live forever? On one hand, because they are mortals, they should die, but these are the Undying Lands. My sister contends that they go they just to rest until they die, Frodo particularly, because he was the Ringbearer. She uses the kinslaying and the fact that Feanor's mother died as examples of people dying in Valinor. So, do they die??