Similar to App's thread "Live or Die," but this one focuses on whether people deserves/deserved to live or die. Not everyone has read the books. GoT spoilers are permitted, since you need to have read up to there to be in the Guild, but if you're posting CoK, SoS, or AFFC stuff, provide spoiler warnings and change the color to white. EDIT: Never mind. It's impossible to have a good discussion under these conditions. So WARNING! Material up to SoS is considered fair game; AFFC material must still be typed in white, however. Rhaegar? NOTE: This title was kindly contributed by App, and it's awesome!