Ok...so I want to rant about the ending of the Amber Spyglass and why Pullman ****ed up such a good trilogy with such an annoying ending which can actually be pulled apart. Firstly....he says that they cannot live together because after 10 years you start becoming sing. Fair enough. But then they can just move between worlds to cure this. Yet it says they cannot do this because all the openings means a loss of dust. But dust is created more than it it lost. Firstly because that main hole down in hell was closed by the angels, and not to mention the angels went around closing every other hole. Secondly, dust is created much faster than it dissapers. Why? because dust is created just by something having though. And with the huge populations in each universe the amount of dust created far out weighs the amount of dust lost considering all the holes have been closed up. Then he goes to to say that the Spectres created through each hole being opened is not fair on the people in the italian sounding place. But that cannot be right. The spectre's are created from that huge gap down in hell, and that gap was closed up by the angels, which again doesn't fit. So all in all, I am pissed of because it wasn't a happy ending, and to top it all, the reasons for the ending did not even agree with what else happened in the book. I really hope he releases a new book or trilogy fixing this.