Discussion in 'Debates' started by finrod, Dec 1, 2003.
which is your fav. Tolkien book?
Book of lost tales.
LOTR definitely- I like the big epic story
It's pretty close between the Sil and LOTR for me. I like UT and the bits of HoM I have read, but because its more information driven, it can't compare to the Sil/LOTR. The Hobbit is a nice story, but perhaps a bit to easy and rather primitive for my liking.
hmmm, why did I create three threads on this?
that was not my intent for sure, I must be stupid!
lol, you're rough on yourself.
I'll go with LoTR
I shall choose BOLT because i really enjoyed reading it
I had a hard time choosing between the Silm and BoLT, by the way.
Yes they are very similar i liked the part in BOLT when the 3 old men give manwe the moon and sun ropes
Yes, I remember that one. I also liked the cottage of lost play thing. These things give middle-earth a different turn.
the only thing I didn't like is the fact that tol-eressea is now England
yeah that was kinda weird then i guess ME is america
ooohhh, can I get to be Utumno, please?
ok then whos aule?
I must say The Hobbit. I thought it was hillarious. and Return of the King. Except for the ending, I didn't really care for that last chapter too much.
You didn't like the last chapter?!?! It was one of the best I thought. And, after saying thus, LOTR is my favorite Tolkien book, although the Silmarillion comes in a close second.
I loved reading the silmarillion, as it helped a 12 year old make sense of lotr. ( I HAVE grown since then) By the way, what is BOLT?
To Isis: I like your douglas Adams quote. Have you read the one on pages 2 to about 6 in Mostly harmless? vv good
BOLT stands for "Book of Lost Tales".
I think the Silmarillion is the best. My absolute favorite Tolkein book.
I must say Lord of the Rings. I just started reading Silmarillion. Hope its good!
The Silm is great
Well, I enjoyed the book of unfinished tales...
But hell, I'v read th LotR's to know its my favorite
Separate names with a comma.