Yes, that IS arrogant. You have absolutely no way to discern who knows most about these movies of you and me, since you know absolutely nothing about me. Except, that is, for the fact that we disagree. But maybe you are just generally of the impression that you know best? I DO make difference between the character and the actor, the way I see it, it is Haydens portrayel that is whiny. Luke was also complaining in the original films, Mark Hamil (who is not much of an actor by the way) did not come around as whiny the same way as Hayden does. Furthermore the OT is far from golden in my eyes. The Return of the Jedi is the worst of the whole bunch. "With episode II he tried to display a romance that was based on 30's movies, romances that were often OTT, but that is what he wanted and if people don't like that kind of acting anymore now, then that's their problems... Maybe they should try to watch more old movies" Yes, it did strike me as very similar to Sound of Music at times. Thanks for making my point for me.